PDF Ebook Marriage of Likeness Same-Sex Unions in Pre-Modern Europe, by John Boswell
It is not secret when linking the creating skills to reading. Reading Marriage Of Likeness Same-Sex Unions In Pre-Modern Europe, By John Boswell will certainly make you get even more sources and resources. It is a way that could boost how you forget and also comprehend the life. By reading this Marriage Of Likeness Same-Sex Unions In Pre-Modern Europe, By John Boswell, you can greater than what you get from various other publication Marriage Of Likeness Same-Sex Unions In Pre-Modern Europe, By John Boswell This is a popular publication that is published from popular author. Seen type the writer, it can be trusted that this book Marriage Of Likeness Same-Sex Unions In Pre-Modern Europe, By John Boswell will offer numerous inspirations, about the life as well as experience as well as every little thing within.
Marriage of Likeness Same-Sex Unions in Pre-Modern Europe, by John Boswell
PDF Ebook Marriage of Likeness Same-Sex Unions in Pre-Modern Europe, by John Boswell
This is it guide Marriage Of Likeness Same-Sex Unions In Pre-Modern Europe, By John Boswell to be best seller recently. We give you the best deal by obtaining the stunning book Marriage Of Likeness Same-Sex Unions In Pre-Modern Europe, By John Boswell in this website. This Marriage Of Likeness Same-Sex Unions In Pre-Modern Europe, By John Boswell will not just be the sort of book that is hard to locate. In this site, all kinds of books are offered. You can search title by title, author by author, as well as author by author to figure out the very best book Marriage Of Likeness Same-Sex Unions In Pre-Modern Europe, By John Boswell that you can review now.
Reading Marriage Of Likeness Same-Sex Unions In Pre-Modern Europe, By John Boswell is a quite valuable interest and doing that can be gone through whenever. It indicates that checking out a book will not restrict your task, will certainly not force the time to invest over, and also won't invest much money. It is a really affordable and reachable thing to acquire Marriage Of Likeness Same-Sex Unions In Pre-Modern Europe, By John Boswell Yet, with that said extremely low-cost thing, you could get something new, Marriage Of Likeness Same-Sex Unions In Pre-Modern Europe, By John Boswell something that you never ever do and also enter your life.
A new encounter can be gained by reading a book Marriage Of Likeness Same-Sex Unions In Pre-Modern Europe, By John Boswell Also that is this Marriage Of Likeness Same-Sex Unions In Pre-Modern Europe, By John Boswell or other book collections. Our company offer this publication since you can find much more points to motivate your ability as well as understanding that will certainly make you a lot better in your life. It will be likewise helpful for individuals around you. We advise this soft file of the book below. To understand the best ways to obtain this book Marriage Of Likeness Same-Sex Unions In Pre-Modern Europe, By John Boswell, learn more right here.
You could find the web link that our company offer in website to download Marriage Of Likeness Same-Sex Unions In Pre-Modern Europe, By John Boswell By acquiring the affordable cost as well as get completed downloading, you have finished to the first stage to get this Marriage Of Likeness Same-Sex Unions In Pre-Modern Europe, By John Boswell It will be nothing when having bought this book as well as not do anything. Read it and also expose it! Invest your couple of time to simply review some sheets of web page of this publication Marriage Of Likeness Same-Sex Unions In Pre-Modern Europe, By John Boswell to review. It is soft data as well as simple to review wherever you are. Enjoy your brand-new routine.
- Sales Rank: #2904978 in Books
- Published on: 1996
- Format: Import
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 1
- Binding: Paperback
- 412 pages
Most helpful customer reviews
118 of 131 people found the following review helpful.
People just don't want to consider that what they believe to be true might not be.
By William Sommerwerck
In reviewing other reviews of this book, it's apparent that those approving of it / objecting to it are mostly people who approve of / object to same-sex marriage. Which tells us little about the book's veracity or validity.
There are no truly neutral observers, simply variations in the degree to which one is prejudiced toward or against a particular position. This book is so heavily footnoted and appendixed, and Boswell seems to be at such pains to clarify exactly what he is and is not claiming, and why, that it is hard to believe he is not being intellectually honest, despite the fact he had a vested interest in promoting same-sex marriage. In short, Boswell gives at least the illusion of objectivity. This is enhanced by the fact that he builds his argument over many chapters, showing the social context into which church-authorized same-sex unions fit, rather than presenting documentation on just the unions -- a point which most of his detractors conveniently overlook.
The bias -- and carelessness -- of some reviewers is blatant. Kevin Davis states "...Boswell argues that rituals for the binding of two males (in Eastern Christendom) between the 12th and 16th centuries is evidence of the support for same-sex marriages in earlier Christianity. This is yet another example of a scholar misinterpreting historical facts in order to serve an agenda."
Anyone who paid attention while reading this book knows that the preceding statement is mostly untrue. (For example, the rituals existed for over 1000 years, and were in use in other parts of Cristendom.) Boswell explicitly states, repeatedly, that these same-sex unions were not, as far as the ceremony itself went, marriage ceremonies (which is why the book has the title it does), and he repeatedly shows how they differ (though the difference is not huge). He does, however, draw a distinction between what is written in a ceremony, and how people perceive the ceremony, suggesting that "the populace" might have viewed the union as a marriage (though not necessarily with a sexual element).
"matt" states "I would suggest that we all need to be careful in reading into texts and history what would make us feel better about ourselves." Agreed. But what about reading text and history based on what we currently perceive as true or false, right or wrong? matt conveniently forgets that "the church" systematically persecuted homosexual men and women for a thousand years -- and he's surprised when some of them are happy to find a bit of history that indicates the church at one time supported (if probably only unintentionally) their affectional preferences?
Which brings us to the issue of the essentialist / constructivist argument. Throughout the book, Boswell (it seems to me) leans in the constructivist direction, by attempting to interpret everything in the context of how the people of the time would have seen or valued it. This is far from trying to force a "modern" homo / hetero perspective on the analysis, which many critics seem to accuse Boswell of doing. (They, of course, do the same thing, but from "the other side".)
Those disagreeing with Boswell do so primarily by grossly misreading him, by taking his arguments out of context, or out of simple prejudice. They don't want to believe his interpretation might be correct.
There is another set of "facts" not discussed (or even mentioned) in this book. One is that homosexual practice between consenting adult males (I'm deliberately omitting paederasty, the love of young men, violation of slaves & prisoners, etc) is not unheard-of historically (qv, the pagan Celts). A berdache was often married to a man of the tribe (see Ruth Benedict), who presumably enjoyed sodomizing another male.
I don't believe Boswell is guilty of stirring up a hornet's next by means of bad scholarship or specious reasoning. He doesn't seem to be indulging in either.
As (the non-gay) friendly Professor Peter Schickele likes to say... "Truth is truth. You can't have opinions about truth." Boswell's interpretation of the historical evidence is almost certainly correct.
44 of 55 people found the following review helpful.
Read this NOW!!
By A Customer
After reading this fine book, I wished that there was some way I could thank Boswell for such a revelation. Knowing that this would be impossible since he passed away, there is no way to thank him, but simply to praise his work, and tell other people about it. This study in same-sex unions performed throughout premodern European history debunks the notiont that marriage was only performed between a male and a female. The book presents astounding facts and information that has been suppressed, or misinterpreted by homophobe bias. In the appendices of the book, there are actual transcriptions of the same-sex marriage ceremonies used, in the vernacular, and translated by Boswell into English. This study was made all the more fascinating by the wealth of footnotes. When Boswell came across an ambiguous word that could mean many things in different languages, he includes that specific word written in its own language in the text. The appearance of these arcane languages in the text were beautiful, and one could call them "eye candy." There was writing from ancient Greece, some Slavic languages, and Hebrew. This novel is a major contribution to European history, and history in general, and being a college student and a future professional historian myself, I am glad to know that Boswell's presence graced the field of history, and has brought the craft of history to new heights.
34 of 45 people found the following review helpful.
Worthy of consideration, but...
By John P. Day
The "but" is well expressed in the last two reviews here. The issue revolves around a specific translation question, and it's a debatable one.
Father Kurt's review comes closest to mine. It takes careful reading,and it has some significant problems, but it does present the issues fairly, and many of the objections made in recent reviews are addressed in the book's text. It may well be arguing a debatable proposition, but it is not "intellectual claptrap". Dr. Boswell makes a game effort to argue that his documents are speaking of something more significant than proerty transfers or normal "friendships". It's quite another thing as to whether he succeeds.
Evaluating this book as a historian, I fond myself at a loss for the lingustic skills to make much of a judgement on most of his texts. His argument, if he could maintsin the linguistic argument in the context in which the documents were produced, otherwise is well put. To repeat, it is not "claptrap".
However, there was one exception where I do have some ability to assess one of his documents: an excerpt in Latin from Giraldus Cambriensis' "History and Topography of Ireland".
Dr. Boswell lays out the Latin text, then gives his translation, and then explains his justification for translating it in the way it does. All of which is quite proper. I had a run at the Latin myself, and while, yes, using some standard definitons, you CAN translate it the way he does, it works equally well as a rite for the formal allaince of families or kinship groups. Since the social structure of Ireland at the time was based almost entirely on kinship groups, that's the way scholars of Irish history would translate it, rather than as a form of personal union between two people. Charitably, one might suppose that 12th century Ireland was not familiar ground for him judging from his other work, it wasn't), so while he seems to have misunderstood the context here, I wouldn't say that he got it wrong elsewhere. I did find a factual error in one of his footnotes (there is another modern translation of which he was apparently unaware), although it was the type of slip which happens fairly easily.
Simply for that reason I've given, I would not take this book as more than advancing an ingenious hypothesis, which remains at best unproven. Still, it is worthy of consideration...and as far as scholarly works go, it's pretty readable. That in itself is a virtue!
Marriage of Likeness Same-Sex Unions in Pre-Modern Europe, by John Boswell PDF
Marriage of Likeness Same-Sex Unions in Pre-Modern Europe, by John Boswell EPub
Marriage of Likeness Same-Sex Unions in Pre-Modern Europe, by John Boswell Doc
Marriage of Likeness Same-Sex Unions in Pre-Modern Europe, by John Boswell iBooks
Marriage of Likeness Same-Sex Unions in Pre-Modern Europe, by John Boswell rtf
Marriage of Likeness Same-Sex Unions in Pre-Modern Europe, by John Boswell Mobipocket
Marriage of Likeness Same-Sex Unions in Pre-Modern Europe, by John Boswell Kindle
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar